Coal India and an IRP Infratech consortium asked for no per-kg incentive in India's ₹7,280 crore magnet scheme, against a cap of ₹2,150. SiliconIndia reported the bids on 10 November, with 16 of 20 bids qualifying for the financial round. Awards are not final and the scheme allows two years for setup. A nil bid buys a strategic position and says nothing about whether the plant earns a return.
BMW avoided the problem in its motor design. Its Gen6 rear axle uses an externally excited synchronous motor that avoids rare earths, and the iX3 M60 xDrive with a revised version starts production at Debrecen in spring 2027.
That motor weighs around 125 kg and produces 200 to 300 kW, and Indian volume sits in two-wheelers and small cars. We think India's near-term route is reduced heavy rare earth content or ferrite designs at lower power, with magnet-free motors coming first in larger SUVs and buses. A two-wheeler motor needs far less power than BMW's, which is where ferrite's lower output costs least. We found no cost comparison at Indian price points, so this is judgment.
China froze magnet exports to India in mid-2025, then licensed a few India-based suppliers from October 2025, on condition that the magnets not go to the US or to defence use. On 9 November it extended its pause on the wider October 2025 controls only to 10 January 2027. The licensing requirement it imposed in April 2025, under which those Indian licences were granted, is outside that pause. A two-month horizon is the exposure a design line insures against.
Fund a magnet-reduced or ferrite design line this year for two-wheelers and small cars, and magnet-free for SUVs and buses. We expect fewer than three of the five planned plants will produce at rated capacity by end 2029, because low bids speed selection and do nothing for the learning curve in magnet making. Award letters, expected in the first half of 2027, are the first test.
Sources (8)
- BMWBlog, BMW Gen6 electric motors
- Automotive World, BMW iX3 M60 xDrive brings 603 hp to first Neue Klasse SUV
- Embassy of India, Sweden, reproducing the Government of India release on the scheme
- SiliconIndia, Coal India, IRP Seek No Subsidies Under India's Rare Earth Magnet Manufacturing Scheme (10 November 2026)
- Nikkei Asia, Indian carmakers scramble in face of China rare earth curbs
- IFCI, REPM scheme details (incentive capped at ₹2,150 per kg)
- Autocar Professional, China grants licence to Indian companies to import rare earth magnets (October 2025)
- The Star (Asia News Network), China extends suspension of rare earth export controls until January (9 November 2026)
