A founder picking a peer adviser can judge candidates by how they manage their own people, on the evidence of a randomised trial in Mysore. In January 2016 the founders of 100 high-growth technology firms were paired with peers at a three-day retreat, at random. Two years later, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning found, founders paired with a peer one standard deviation more active in managing people, roughly weekly against monthly practice, had firms 28% larger and 10 percentage points more likely to survive. For the median firm the authors put that at an additional 2.5 employees retained and survival rising from 75% to 85%. The published version, in the Strategic Management Journal in 2019, describes the contrast as formal against informal management.
The management index behind those numbers counts how often a founder sets shared goals with staff and gives them feedback. Founders with MBAs or accelerator experience did not respond to the advice.
A trial in Kenya, published in the American Economic Journal, also favoured a person over a programme. Mentorship by an experienced local entrepreneur raised profits by 20 percent on average, with effects fading as matches ended, and a formal business course had no effect on profits. Those were inexperienced women running microenterprises in a Nairobi slum. The Mysore study covers startup founders at one retreat and advice given over days, and says nothing direct about salaried CXOs or a long mentoring relationship.
Ask a prospective adviser how often they meet their own team and set goals, then ask to see the calendar, because the calendar shows the habit the trial measured. A founder with an MBA might look for market or sector knowledge instead; neither study tests that, so it is our guess.
Sources (3)
- NBER Working Paper 24789, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning, When Does Advice Impact Startup Performance?
- Strategic Management Journal 40(3): 331-356, 2019, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning, When does advice impact startup performance? DOI 10.1002/smj.2987
- American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, Brooks, Donovan and Johnson, Mentors or Teachers? Microenterprise Training in Kenya

