Skip to main content
India's Premier Invitation-Only Executive Network
insights iconMentorshipmentorship

Indian founders advised by active managers had 28% more staff; MBAs showed little response

T
Tejvir Singh
2 min read
2 min read

A founder picking a peer adviser can judge candidates by how they manage their own people, on the evidence of a randomised trial in Mysore. In January 2016 the founders of 100 high-growth technology firms were paired with peers at a three-day retreat, at random. Two years later, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning found, founders paired with a peer one standard deviation more active in managing people, roughly weekly against monthly practice, had firms 28% larger and 10 percentage points more likely to survive. For the median firm the authors put that at an additional 2.5 employees retained and survival rising from 75% to 85%. The published version, in the Strategic Management Journal in 2019, describes the contrast as formal against informal management.

The management index behind those numbers counts how often a founder sets shared goals with staff and gives them feedback. Founders with MBAs or accelerator experience did not respond to the advice.

A trial in Kenya, published in the American Economic Journal, also favoured a person over a programme. Mentorship by an experienced local entrepreneur raised profits by 20 percent on average, with effects fading as matches ended, and a formal business course had no effect on profits. Those were inexperienced women running microenterprises in a Nairobi slum. The Mysore study covers startup founders at one retreat and advice given over days, and says nothing direct about salaried CXOs or a long mentoring relationship.

Ask a prospective adviser how often they meet their own team and set goals, then ask to see the calendar, because the calendar shows the habit the trial measured. A founder with an MBA might look for market or sector knowledge instead; neither study tests that, so it is our guess.

Sources (3)
  1. NBER Working Paper 24789, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning, When Does Advice Impact Startup Performance?
  2. Strategic Management Journal 40(3): 331-356, 2019, Chatterji, Delecourt, Hasan and Koning, When does advice impact startup performance? DOI 10.1002/smj.2987
  3. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, Brooks, Donovan and Johnson, Mentors or Teachers? Microenterprise Training in Kenya

More from CXO India

Executive insights, market intelligence, and leadership spotlights — curated for India's C-suite.